How many holiday rentals are available around Fire Island?

Our 2020 accommodation listings offer a large selection of 650 holiday lettings around Fire Island. From 572 houses to 24 flats & apartments, find unique self catering accommodation for you to enjoy a memorable stay with your family and friends for a long holiday or a weekend break.

Can I rent a seaside property in Fire Island?

Oh I do like to be beside the seaside... said everyone ever. Find the perfect home away from home for your group and you'll be well on your way to beachy bliss. HomeAway has 237 beachside getaway homes for you to select from. Of course, that mightn't work for everyone. Fortunately, HomeAway has plenty of other choices, including:

  • 152 water-view holiday accommodation options.
  • 107 ocean-view holiday accommodation options.
  • 102 beach-view holiday accommodation options.

Can I rent a house in Fire Island?

If you want an authentic holiday experience and don't feel like sharing space with strangers this time round, renting an entire house is the way to go. There are 561 options currently on HomeAway. Prices start from £31 per night. Or perhaps you'd prefer one of the area's other popular self-catering accommodation options, like:

  • Cottage: 33 self-catering accommodation options. Prices start from £99 per night.
  • Apartment: 21 self-catering accommodation options. Prices start from £38 per night.
  • Hotel: 12 self-catering accommodation options. Prices start from £69 per night.

Can I stay in Fire Island in a large group?

The recipe for a memorable trip is hanging out with friends and family in an amazing new place. If you're visiting with a large group, HomeAway can help. House holiday rentals are the leading choice for large groups of visitors, with 133 available here. Rental properties in this area that are perfect for large groups include:

  • If yours is a party of 8, we offer 145 rental properties perfect for that size. Spend a night from just £211.
  • Keen to find a rental property for 10 people? We have 117 that will suit. Prices start from £230 a night.
  • Organising a trip away with a group of 6? We've got 115 rental accommodation that will be perfect. Prices begin at just £77 a night.

So don't fret! When you travel with us you'll be able to bring your dad, your cousin and all your besties to Fire Island.

Where are the cheapest holiday rentals in Fire Island?

Show the door to soulless chain-hotel rooms! Savour the flexibility of living like a local in a budget-friendly holiday rental instead. Feast your eyes on the incredible options available to book on HomeAway. Dunewood is a bargain-hunter's dream. And with 25 HomeAway holiday rentals at an average price of £470 a night, it's not difficult to see why. Lonelyville is another place to consider. We've got 30 and the average price is around £493 a night.